SEO competitor analysis: how to do it in one day

Work out your real search competitors from the results page, put their pages in a table, read their site structure by hand and turn what you find into three decisions.

· 13 min readSEO

Short answer

SEO competitor analysis means studying the sites that appear on the results page for your target queries, which may differ from your business rivals. You put their pages in a table, read site structure and links by hand, and turn the findings into three decisions: what to write, strengthen and drop.

Picture this: an invented kitchen cabinet workshop searches for “how to measure for kitchen cabinets” and cannot find itself in the results. None of the rival firms it knows from the trade are there either. The first page holds a home magazine’s guide, a forum thread, a store chain’s blog and a video page. The workshop’s business rivals are one list and its search rivals are another. The practical answer to how to do SEO competitor analysis is to build the second list, read those pages one by one and end with three decisions. A small team can do this in a day.

The firm and the table in this article are invented; we wrote them only to show the method. We assume your query list is ready. If it is not, start with how to do keyword research; to read the want behind a query, there is what search intent is and how to find it. The subject here is reading the pages that sit in the results, in order.

The seven steps of an SEO competitor review: collect, read and three decisions Collect Read Decide 1 Rival list from the results 2 Page table 3 Topics you do not cover 4 Structure and internal links 5 Link information (limited) 6 Technical basics and PageSpeed 7 Three decisions Page to write Page to strengthen Topic to drop The seven steps of an SEO competitor review: collect, read and three decisions Collect 1 Rival list from the results 2 Page table 3 Topics you do not cover Read 4 Structure and internal links 5 Link information (limited) 6 Technical basics and PageSpeed Decide 7 Three decisions Page to write Page to strengthen Topic to drop
Figure: A competitor review starts by collecting the results pages, continues by reading pages and sites, and ends in three decisions: what to write, what to strengthen and what to drop.

1. Build the rival list from your own queries

A business rival is a firm that sells the same thing to the same customer. A search rival is every site on the results page for a query you are targeting: it can be a magazine, a forum, a public body, a store or a video channel. Your page is trying to rank in their company. This distinction is our working definition; it is not a Google term.

Build the list like this:

  1. Pick the five to eight queries you care about most from your query list. If you have no list, look at the queries in Search Console’s performance report and at what customers ask you.
  2. Search each query and write down the domains on the first page. Also note the day and the device you searched from; this is our suggestion.
  3. Mark the domains that appear for at least two queries. These are your real search rivals.

2. Put every result page in a table

In the table, write what the page is rather than its position number. The table below shows the five results the invented workshop saw on the first page for “how to measure for kitchen cabinets”; every row is made up as an example.

Position Page type Depth Freshness Written by
1 Magazine guide Step by step, with drawings Updated this year Named editor
2 Store chain blog Short, mostly a measurement table No date No author given
3 Forum thread Readers’ own experiences Old thread, new replies Forum members
4 Workshop site Medium length, with photos Last year Signed, by the workshop owner
5 Video page Explanation in the video, little text This year Channel owner

The columns draw on the self-assessment questions on Google’s helpful content page. That page offers the questions for weighing your own content; asking them of a rival’s page is our adaptation.

  • Page type: Compare it with the type of your own page. If the types do not match, start with the route in the search intent article.
  • Depth: How completely does the page cover the topic? Google’s page asks whether the content gives a substantial, complete or comprehensive description of the topic, and whether it gives substantial value compared with other pages in the results. The same page also asks whether you are writing to a particular word count, and notes in brackets that Google has no preferred word count. Measure depth by the number of sub-questions answered, not by word count.
  • Freshness: Does the date on the page show that the content is truly current? The same page also asks whether page dates are being changed when the content has not substantially changed.
  • Written by: Does the page give an author, sources and something about the publisher? Google’s page asks whether the content is presented in a way that makes you want to trust it, and whether it is written or reviewed by someone who demonstrably knows the topic well.

In the example, details such as drawings and a named editor appear on only one page. That may be a gap the workshop can fill from its own measuring experience; we test it in the next step.

3. Find what you do not cover

Open each page in the table and copy its subheadings into a list. Then sort the questions into three groups: those on all pages, those on one or two pages, and those on none. The first group holds the topic’s basic questions, and your page has to answer them too. The third group is your possible difference, but only if it is something you really know.

Google’s helpful content page asks two questions here: does the content provide original information, research or analysis, and does it clearly show first-hand expertise and depth of knowledge? For the example workshop, that could mean describing measuring mistakes made in real kitchens, which the other pages lack. Do not write about a topic that none of them covers if you do not know it yourself.

The gaps you find go into the angle section of the brief you give your writer. See how to write a content brief for that.

Open the sites of the two or three rivals that appear most and look at how a visitor reaches the ranking page:

  • How many clicks from the menu? Can you reach the page from the home page through the menu, or can it only be found from search results?
  • The address. Google’s SEO starter guide recommends using words in the URL that are useful to users, and calls URLs made of random identifiers less helpful. Do the rival’s addresses say what the page is about?
  • Link text. The same guide says link text tells users and Google something about the page being linked to. With what text, and from which pages, does the rival link to that page? “Click here”, or a phrase that names the topic?
  • How many pages on the topic? Type a search such as site:domain.example measurement into the search box. The guide recommends the site: operator for checking whether your own site is in the index; using it on a rival is our own method; do not read the result as a full count.

To set what you find beside your own site, the steps in how to do internal linking will help. For the term, see the glossary entry on internal links.

The SEO starter guide says Google primarily finds pages through links from other pages it has already crawled, and that other sites linking to you happens naturally over time. Links are therefore part of a rival review, but the part you can see for free is narrow.

  • Your own site’s links. According to the Search Console help page, the Links report shows the links to your site. The same page says the report is not a complete list of every link, that it shows a sample, and that it does not say whether a link is nofollow. This report describes your site; you will not find the equivalent for a rival in it (our inference).
  • A hand check on a rival. Search the title of a rival page in quotation marks and read the sites that mention it: trade publications, suppliers, associations. This method gives incomplete results; you cannot know which links you found or how many you missed.
  • Paid tools. Some paid tools estimate a rival’s link list, and some show a number they produce themselves, such as an “authority score”. That number is the tool’s own estimate. Our view is that it is not a measure Google uses; do not make it a target.

Buying or selling links for ranking purposes appears among the examples of link spam in Google’s spam policies. You cannot know how a rival’s links were earned, so do not treat them as a route to copy. For honest routes, there is what a backlink is and how to get one; the glossary entry on backlinks gives the short definition.

6. Check the technical basics with a browser and PageSpeed Insights

Open each page in the table on your phone and see whether it is readable and whether an ad or pop-up blocks the content. Read the title tag and the main heading. Then paste the page address into PageSpeed Insights.

According to the PageSpeed Insights about page, the tool reports on a page for both mobile and desktop and offers lab data and real-user data together. The real-user data comes from the previous 28-day period. If the page has too little data, the tool falls back to data for the whole site; if that has none either, no real-user data is shown. On a rival’s small page you may therefore see only lab data (our inference). A page passes the Core Web Vitals assessment if the 75th percentiles of all three metrics are in the good range. To compare your own values with the thresholds, there is the Core Web Vitals checker.

Do not make too much of a technical gap. The SEO starter guide says that creating content people find compelling and useful will likely influence your site’s presence in search results more than any of the other suggestions in the guide. Test your own technical groundwork with the technical SEO checklist.

7. Turn the findings into three decisions

The table and the notes are input for decisions, not a document. Our suggestion is to end every review with exactly three decisions:

  1. A page to write. One of the gaps from step 3: which question, for which query, written by whom?
  2. A page to strengthen. A page you already have that is missing something in internal links, title or coverage, judged by the findings in steps 4 and 5.
  3. A topic to drop. If the whole first page is full of kinds of page you cannot offer (for example a public body or a user forum), do not write a page for that query for now.

Put an owner and a date beside each decision. The SEO starter guide says changes can take anywhere from a few hours to several months, and suggests that in general you wait a few weeks before judging the effect of your work.

What not to copy

  • The text. Google’s spam policies define scraping as taking content from other sites and hosting it to manipulate search rankings. The examples they list include republishing content without adding anything original, and copying content, changing it only slightly with synonyms or automated techniques, and republishing it. The SEO starter guide also tells you not to copy others’ content in part or in its entirety. The helpful content page asks whether content that draws on other sources avoids simply copying or rewriting them.
  • The word count. The helpful content page says Google has no preferred word count.
  • The date. Do not do the same just because a rival refreshed a date; changing page dates when the content has not changed is one of the warning questions on Google’s helpful content page.
  • The assumed reason for the ranking. You cannot tell from the table why the top-ranked page is first; there may be reasons you cannot copy, such as how well known the brand is. This is our view.

Common mistakes

  • Trusting a single search. Keep the table with its date and fill it in again when one of your pages loses queries.
  • Treating the top-ranked page as a flawless model. A page can carry the best and the worst of the table; read each column separately.
  • Leaving the findings as a report. An item with no owner and no date does not get done.
  • Expecting results in the first week. As the guide says, wait a few weeks and then look at the table again.

Common questions

Do I need a paid tool for SEO competitor analysis?

This method needs no paid tool and is enough for a small team’s first round (our view). Paid tools, such as Ahrefs or Semrush, offer query and link lists. We say nothing here about the accuracy of their data; if you use one, read the tool’s own documentation.

How often should I repeat a competitor review?

We cannot suggest a fixed interval. When one of your pages loses queries, or before you write a new page, fill in the table for that query again.

Can I take a rival’s page and rewrite it?

No. Google’s spam policies list copying content from other sites, changing it only slightly and republishing it among the examples of scraping. From someone else’s page, learn only what is missing, and write it with your own knowledge.

The shortest way to try this today: search your most important query, write the first-page results into a five-row table and add your own page underneath as a sixth row. When you see which column you fall behind in, your first decision is ready. If you would like to build the query and page match together, the SEO service page says our keyword and intent map is a single table showing which query belongs to which page.

Sources

This article is general information, not legal, financial or technical advice. Platforms, their rules and the law change over time, so some details may have changed since 14 November 2026 or contain small errors. Before you make a decision for your business, check the current official sources or write to us.

Tell us about
your project.

Fill in the form or write to us directly, and we will agree on a day to talk.

Your first meeting is with Deniz Sezer, founder of Detmore.

First meeting free · Reply within one working day · Written proposal in 2 to 3 days · NDA ready

What do you need? pick as many as you like

Name, email and phone are required.

Contact

We reply within one working day.