Short answer
The most reliable way to choose a digital agency is to compare written answers to the same questions before you sign: who your day-to-day contact is, whose name the accounts are in, what will be measured, what happens in the first 90 days and how you exit. Be wary of any agency that guarantees rankings or sales.
The most common mistake in choosing an agency is deciding on the strength of the sales pitch and the portfolio. Every agency shows a good portfolio, and every proposal looks neat. The difference shows up in the first months of the work and on the day you part ways: who you are talking to, whose name the accounts are in, what you are measuring, what happens if you want to leave. This article answers how to choose a digital agency with twelve concrete questions: the ones we suggest you ask before you request a proposal and before you sign, and how to read the answers. We are an agency too; we would want these questions asked of us as well.
Ask yourself first
Before you put questions to an agency, write down two things. First, the event where your business actually makes money: a sale, a qualified quote request, an appointment or a registration. Second, what you want to have changed six months from now. “Bring our social media to life” can’t be measured, so it doesn’t count as a goal. “Track the quote requests that come from our website properly, and grow them” does. Without these two sentences, every proposal looks alike and the one that seems cheapest wins. To turn these two sentences and the rest of what an agency needs into one page, see how to brief a digital agency.
What to look for when choosing a digital agency: 12 questions
1. Who will I talk to day to day?
The person who comes to the sales meeting is often not the person who will run the work. Ask: “Once the work starts, who will write to me, and how quickly will a question get an answer?” A good answer includes a name and a role. “Our team will take care of it” is vague. As well as your point of contact, find out who does each part of the work: who does the design, who goes into the ad account, who writes the content.
2. In whose name will the accounts be opened?
Ad accounts, analytics properties, the tag manager, the domain, the server, social media pages and marketplace stores should be opened in your name, with the agency added as an authorised user. With an ad campaign run from the agency’s own account, the historical data leaves with the agency when you do. A domain registered in the agency’s name is a similar risk. The platforms work this way too. In Google Ads, the agency links your account to its own manager account; according to Google’s documentation, that link doesn’t transfer ownership of the account to the agency, and a user with admin access to the account can remove it. In Meta, the agency is added as a partner to the assets in your business portfolio. In GA4, holding the Administrator role on the property means you decide who is added and removed. We show how to keep who holds which level on which account in a one-page register in who owns your ad and analytics accounts. Close this question with a written answer.
3. How is the ad budget paid?
Ask whether the budget goes straight to the platform, paid by your card or invoiced to you, or whether it passes through the agency. If it passes through the agency, find out how you will see how much of the spend actually reaches the platform. Having the agency fee and the media budget on separate lines makes it clear what you are paying for. If you are looking for a team for ads management alone, how to choose a Google Ads agency goes through what to check, from account ownership to the fee model.
4. What will we measure, and how will it be reported?
“We do reporting” is not enough. Ask which numbers will be looked at, where those numbers will come from, and how often and in what form they will reach you. Numbers such as impressions, likes and followers look good on their own but don’t tell you what happened to the business. If tracking isn’t in place, setting it up is the first job; raising the budget before that is spending you can’t read the results of. We cover this separately in measure before you raise the budget. You can see how we report on ongoing work in our article on the Monday report.
5. What will happen in the first 90 days?
A good agency can walk you through the first three months week by week: which access will be requested, when tracking will be checked, when the first delivery will arrive, on what date the first decision point falls. If the only answer is “we will develop a strategy”, ask them to fill it in. Ask what will be expected of you, too; delays with content, approvals and access are the most common reason the first months slip.
6. How long is the contract, and how do I get out?
Ask about the term, the notice period and what will be handed over when you leave. A long commitment is understandable for some work; SEO, for example, takes time. But if the exit terms are vague or the penalty clause is heavy, leaving becomes hard even when the results get worse. The contract should state who owns the accounts, design files, source code, content and past reports on the day you part ways.
7. Is any of the work subcontracted?
Many agencies outsource some work, and it is common practice. What to watch is whether they tell you so openly. Ask which work is done by whom, who has access to your data and who is responsible if there is a quality problem. A clear answer is a good sign; an evasive one is something to watch.
8. Do you guarantee a result?
Promises such as “guaranteed first page”, “a set increase in sales” or “this many followers” are red flags. Search engines, ad platforms and buyer behaviour are not under any agency’s control. Google’s “Do you need an SEO?” guide states plainly that no one can guarantee a #1 ranking on Google, and warns against SEOs who claim to guarantee rankings. What can be guaranteed is not the result but the way of working: what will be done, when it will be delivered, how it will be measured and how you will be told when a problem comes up. We cover the extra questions for the SEO side in how to choose an SEO agency. For automation work, the same kind of list is in how to choose an automation agency.
9. How can I check similar work?
Ask for the live addresses of the work in the portfolio and open them yourself. If you can, ask for a short call with a reference, and ask them to talk about their own experience. The question to ask isn’t “are you happy?” but “what happened when something went wrong?” If there is no example close to your sector or the size of your business, ask about that openly too. If promotion in your sector is regulated separately, find out whether the agency knows those rules as well; for healthcare, we summarise them in social media rules for clinic and doctor accounts.
10. What does the agency’s own website tell you?
If a web agency’s own site loads slowly, falls apart on mobile or has a contact form that doesn’t work, there is little reason to expect it to take more care over yours. Open the agency’s site on your phone, fill in a form and see how long they take to reply. This small test is a more honest preview than the sales meeting. What we found when we measured the home pages of 15 agency websites with free tools is in our agency website measurements.
11. Is the proposal written up item by item?
A single-line monthly fee hides what is included and what isn’t. Ask for each piece of work to be written as a separate item, along with its deliverables; that way you can genuinely compare proposals with one another. If you want to know what makes prices vary, take a look at our article on digital agency pricing.
12. One agency, or several specialists?
There is no single right answer to this for everyone. The advantage of one agency is that the same team sees the website, the advertising, the SEO and the tracking, and when something goes wrong the blame doesn’t get passed around between parties. The drawback is that the agency may not have the same depth in every area, and it may hide the area where it is weak. The advantage of working with several specialists is depth in every area. The drawback is that the coordination falls to you: the ad specialist may blame the website, the SEO specialist may blame the ads, and tracking ends up being nobody’s job. Before choosing, ask the agency which work it does itself, which it gives to others and where it is weak. A team that can say this openly is one you can trust.
Agency or in-house team, agency or freelancer
An in-house team knows your business most closely and is there every day. But it is hard for one person to handle the website, advertising, SEO, content and data with the same depth, and building a team of several people takes time and management. If the work is constant and heavy, an in-house team makes sense. For many businesses, a good route is one person inside who owns the work and a team outside who carries it out.
A freelancer is a fast, flexible option for a single, well-defined job: a landing page, a setup, a period of content. The risk lies in continuity and scope. Illness, holidays or a busy spell can bring the work to a halt, and when the work spreads across several areas, the coordination falls to you again.
An agency suits running several areas together and providing continuity. In return, it takes time to learn your business, and the structure can be too much for small jobs. Whichever you choose, the questions above still apply: account ownership, tracking and exit terms matter just as much with a freelancer.
Which is the best digital agency?
“Best digital agency” lists are often built on awards, size or advertising. The best one for you is the agency that understands the event where your business makes money, writes down what it will measure, keeps your accounts in your name and doesn’t make it hard for you to leave. The way to find that out is through the answers to the questions above. Get proposals from two or three agencies using the same questions, and put the answers side by side.
Our approach
We wrote most of these questions around the way we work ourselves. We run web, automation, e-commerce, SEO, content, social media, advertising, email and data work in one team, with one point of contact. Accounts are opened in your name and handed over when you leave. Your ad budget goes straight to the platform. Proposals come in writing, item by item; for work that needs reporting, we send a short report every Monday. You can find what we do on our services page and who we are on our about page.
Common questions
What is the minimum time to work with an agency?
It depends on the work. Project work, such as a website or a setup, ends with delivery. Ongoing work such as advertising, SEO and content needs a few months before you can read the results; SEO usually takes longer than advertising. More important than the length of the commitment is having in writing what will be delivered in the first months and on what date you will review it together.
What happens to my accounts when I change agency?
If the accounts were opened in your name from the start, nothing is lost; the old agency’s access is removed and the new agency is added. If the accounts are in the agency’s name, the historical data, the campaign structure and sometimes the domain are at risk. That is why you should have account ownership, and what will be handed over when you leave, written into the contract before you sign. We go through the handover in order in changing your ad agency.
How many agencies should I talk to when getting proposals?
Two or three agencies are usually enough. More than that makes comparison harder. Send them all the same goal and the same questions, ask for a written proposal item by item, and read the answers side by side.
Is it sensible to pick the cheapest proposal?
Only if the proposals cover the same work. A low fee often means less work, a less experienced team or items that will be billed separately. Make the scope equal first, then compare the price.
Copy these twelve questions into a document, leave a blank line under each one and send the same document to every agency you speak to. The lines that come back empty, or filled with general phrases, tell you as much as the ones that come back full. You can send that document to us as well: contact page.
Sources
This article is general information, not legal, financial or technical advice. Platforms, their rules and the law change over time, so some details may have changed since 25 October 2026 or contain small errors. Before you make a decision for your business, check the current official sources or write to us.