Short answer
A good SEO agency won’t guarantee rankings; it spells out the work it will do, what it will measure and the plan for the first three months. Ask for a sample report, ask where the links will come from, and make sure you always own your Search Console and Analytics accounts.
There are two proposals on your desk. Both list the same headings: technical SEO, content, links, a monthly report. One promises the first page; the other doesn’t. When you are working out how to choose an SEO agency, the real difference is in what work sits behind those words, what will be measured and what happens when things don’t go as expected. That is usually what the proposal leaves out. In this article we explain which promises to treat with caution when you buy SEO services, what good work looks like and which questions you can ask in the first meeting. We are an SEO agency too, so we have tried to write this guide in a way that lets you judge our own proposal by the same measure.
Why guaranteed SEO is a red flag
Lines such as “first page in three months” or “guaranteed number one for this keyword” sound reassuring. The problem is that rankings are decided by the search engine, not the agency. Google is clear about this on its Search Central page “Do you need an SEO?”: no one can guarantee a number one ranking on Google. The page also says to be wary of agencies that guarantee rankings or claim a special relationship with the search engine.
It isn’t hard to see why a guarantee is impossible. Search results change with your site, with what your competitors are doing, with the location and device of the person searching, and with the updates Google makes to its algorithms. Only the first of these is even partly in your control.
A proposal that offers a guarantee usually involves one of three things:
- The guarantee is for a keyword nobody searches for. Reaching number one for a very long or very narrow phrase is easy, but that search brings you no customers.
- Short-term, risky methods are used. Rankings rise for a while, then fall, or the site is penalised.
- The terms of the guarantee are vague. It doesn’t say on which device, in which city or on which day the ranking will be measured, so the result stays open to dispute.
The only thing that can be guaranteed is the work itself: which problem will be fixed, which page will be written, what will be measured.
The risks of buying cheap links in bulk
Links still matter; other sites linking to you is a sign that your site is a trustworthy source. But the value of that sign comes from the link being given freely, or earned. Packages such as “hundreds of links a month” usually work against that logic.
The risks of bulk link packages are these:
- They break spam policies. Google’s spam policies for web search explicitly treat buying and selling links to influence rankings as a breach of its spam policies. Such links are either ignored or can lead to a manual action against the site.
- The sources are low quality. These links often come from sites set up only to sell links, with no real readers.
- They are hard to clean up. Once the problem is spotted, finding the links one by one and disavowing them where needed takes far more effort than buying them did.
- They take the place of the real work. When the budget goes on links, nothing is left for technical fixes and content.
A healthy link strategy is slower and produces fewer links: appearing in industry publications, creating a guide or tool worth sharing, being listed properly on your business partners’ sites. When you ask an agency where the links will come from, you should hear concrete types of example, not just a number.
What good SEO work should include
The parts of good SEO work are neither new nor secret. The difference lies in the order they are done in and how carefully. We build our own SEO services and SEO consulting on these same parts, but whichever agency you work with, you can expect to see the following in the proposal.
Technical audit
First you need to make sure the site can be crawled and indexed. The audit covers crawl errors, the sitemap, redirects, duplicate pages, noindex and canonical tags, and page speed. The output should be a prioritised list of tasks; a dump of several hundred errors is of little use to anyone on its own. You can run a first pass of this audit yourself with free tools; we set out the steps in our technical SEO checklist. We explain separately how speed affects sales in why a fast site sells more. If you are planning a move to a new site, this step matters even more; our article on keeping SEO through a site rebuild is devoted to it.
Keyword and search intent map
Before deciding which searches you want to appear for, you need to understand what the person making that search wants. Someone searching for a “price” and someone searching for “how to” will not be satisfied by the same page. A good map ties each important search to a single page and reveals pages that compete with each other for the same search. This table is the basis for every decision that follows.
Content plan
The map shows which pages are missing and which need rewriting. The content plan then spreads those gaps across the months as topic clusters. The question to ask here is who will write the content and how the person who knows the subject will take part. Text written by someone who doesn’t know your industry stays weak, both in the search engine and in the reader’s eyes. If you would like to treat content as a separate piece of work, take a look at our content marketing service.
Internal linking
Links between the site’s own pages help both visitors and search engines find their way around. Linking to important pages from related articles, finding orphaned pages and simplifying the menu structure is as effective as external links, and far less risky.
Measurement and the monthly report
The report should show the link between the work done and the result: what was done this month, which number changed, what will be done next month. Rankings and organic traffic can appear in the report, but the real measure should be the enquiries that come from organic search: forms, phone calls, quote requests or sales. We go through the sections of a monthly report one by one in our SEO report guide.
Seven questions for the first meeting
Whether you are talking to an agency or an independent SEO consultant, the questions below let you compare proposals by the same measure. Look at how concrete the answers are, as well as whether they are right.
- What will you report on? Ask for a sample monthly report. See whether it is made up only of charts, or of a written account of the work done and the next step.
- Will you measure rankings, or enquiries and revenue? Ask how forms and sales from organic search will be tracked, and what needs to change in the analytics setup to make that possible.
- Which pages will you touch? Make clear whether changes will be made with your approval, who will have access to the site’s admin panel and how a change will be rolled back if it causes a problem.
- Who will write the content? Ask who the writer and editor are, how your expert knowledge will feed into the process and who gives final approval before publication.
- What is your link strategy? Ask plainly where and how the links will come from, and whether paid links will be used. A vague answer is a piece of information in itself.
- Who will hold the Search Console and Analytics access? You should own the accounts; the agency should only be added as a user. In Search Console, only a property owner can add or remove users and change their permissions. Whether your data and history stay with you when the work ends depends on this.
- What will happen in the first three months? Ask for the work to be done month by month, the deliveries you will see, and what you will look at at the end of the third month to decide whether to continue.
For questions to ask before working with any agency, see our article on how to choose a digital agency.
How long does SEO take to work
The honest answer is that it is measured in months, and it isn’t possible to give an exact time. Fixing technical errors can have a relatively quick effect; especially if important pages aren’t being indexed, the fix can make a difference within a short time. New content and links, on the other hand, usually take longer to show in search. We cover what to expect month by month separately in how long SEO takes.
The main factors that decide the timing are these:
- The site’s current state: a site with a history and a sound technical base doesn’t start from the same place as a newly launched site or one with serious technical problems.
- Competition: making room in searches where large, long-established sites have invested for years takes longer.
- Pace of production: how consistently the planned content and fixes are put into practice decides as much as the agency itself does.
So rather than expecting a jump in rankings in the first months, it is healthier to look at whether the work is being done and at the leading indicators. These are the number of indexed pages, which searches impressions are growing in, the first clicks on new pages.
B2B and SaaS SEO is measured differently
In B2B and SaaS, searches are few but each one is valuable. An industrial product or enterprise software may be searched for only a few dozen times a month, yet the person searching is often in the middle of a buying process. So the agency’s report should go beyond growth in traffic; it should show which pages quote and demo requests come from, and those requests should be matched against the sales team’s records. In the meeting, ask the agency how it will track organic search’s contribution over a long sales cycle. Our guide to B2B SEO covers the differences in detail, and how to build a B2B content plan shows how to plan the pages that bring those requests.
Common questions
Is guaranteed SEO possible?
No. Rankings are decided by the search engine, and Google itself advises caution towards anyone who guarantees rankings. What an agency can guarantee is the scope of the work it will do and the content of the report.
Who should own the Search Console account when working with an SEO agency?
You should. The business should own the account and the agency should only be added as a user. That way, when the work with the agency ends, your data and history stay with you.
How do you measure success in B2B SEO?
By the demo, trial and quote requests that come from organic search, more than by traffic. Because the sales cycle is long, matching those requests against sales records shows organic search’s real contribution.
When the meeting is over, check one more thing: how many questions did the other side ask you? A team that prepares a proposal without asking who your customers are, how a sale closes and what has already been tried on the site is most likely sending everyone the same plan. In a good first meeting, some of the questions come from the agency.
Sources
This article is general information, not legal, financial or technical advice. Platforms, their rules and the law change over time, so some details may have changed since 25 October 2026 or contain small errors. Before you make a decision for your business, check the current official sources or write to us.