Short answer
A marketplace brings ready-made demand, but you share the customer and the price with the platform; your own shop keeps customer, data and brand with you, but you build the demand. Work out profit per order in both with your own numbers, then add the second channel once the first runs smoothly.
On Monday morning the order count on your marketplace dashboard looks good. At the end of the month you open the settlement statement and the amount that reaches you is lower than you expected. In the same week a customer writes to you directly: “can I buy this from your website?” and you don’t have one. Or the other way round: you have your own shop, you paid for the first months of advertising, but everyone looks for the product on a marketplace. Either way the same question comes up: should I sell on a marketplace or in my own online shop? This article gives a six-step order for answering it with your own numbers. We give no commission rates or fees; those are in your seller panel and your contract anyway.
The short frame is this. A marketplace lets you walk into a crowd that is already shopping, and in return you share part of the customer relationship and the price with the platform. Your own shop leaves the customer, the data and the brand entirely with you, and in return you have to build the demand. Which one suits you depends on your product, your margin and your operations.
1. Write down who knows the customer and owns the data
Start with a simple question: when a customer buys from you, who knows them? A person shopping on a marketplace is first of all the platform’s customer. They place the order, pay and leave a review inside the platform’s environment, and the platform’s seller rules decide what information reaches the seller and how far. Read those rules in your seller panel and your contract, because “the customer list is mine” is often a wrong assumption.
On your own shop it is the other way round. Law No. 6563 on the Regulation of Electronic Commerce defines the party that provides the marketplace as an “electronic commerce intermediary service provider” and the seller as an “electronic commerce service provider”. The seller falls under the same definition both on a marketplace and in their own environment. On your own shop you also build the environment, so you decide why and how customer information is collected. Law No. 6698 on the Protection of Personal Data calls the person who decides the purposes and means of processing the “data controller”. That is both an opportunity (repeat purchases, email, campaigns) and a burden: the privacy notice and the consents are your job. For the details, see email and SMS consent in Turkey.
2. See where the demand comes from
The marketplace’s biggest contribution is ready-made demand: people who are already looking for your product and intend to buy are there. On your own shop you build that demand yourself; search, advertising, social media, email and direct visits are all part of the job. To see which side suits you, ask:
- Do people search for your product as a category (“duvet cover set”) or by your brand name? If they search for the category, a marketplace brings you customers; if they search for your brand, your own shop is worth more.
- Is your product easy to tell apart from competitors? If not, you end up in a price race on a marketplace; if it is, on your own shop you tell the story.
- Do the same customers buy again? A repeat customer is someone you win once on your own shop and sell to many times.
Visibility on a marketplace also has a price: listing quality and advertising. For those, see the order in how to improve a marketplace listing and advertising on Trendyol; we don’t repeat it here.
3. List the kinds of cost each channel brings
In this step we write no figures, only the line items. Forgetting an item is the most common profit mistake. The table below shows which kinds of cost wait for you in each channel; don’t leave any row empty, and find your own number for every one.
| Kind of cost | On a marketplace | On your own shop |
|---|---|---|
| Share of the sale | Commission per sale | Payment provider commission |
| Shipping | Shipping terms tied to campaigns and the contract | Your own agreement and what you pass on to the customer |
| Advertising | Sponsored visibility inside the platform | Effort and spend on search, social media and email |
| Platform and software | Usually covered by the store contract | Shop infrastructure, maintenance, security, measurement |
| Returns | Outbound and return shipping, packaging, damaged goods | The same items, plus the work of handling returns |
| Stock errors | Cancellations, seller score and ranking effects | Unhappy customers and lost trust |
| Effort | Listings, answering questions and reviews, campaign calendar | Content, customer service, running the shop |
Don’t underestimate the “stock errors” row. Trendyol’s seller knowledge centre treats failure to supply under its own heading and ties it to seller performance; the seller score is explained on a separate page. So the price of selling a product you don’t have may not end with a cancellation on a marketplace; it can be written into your store’s record too. Read the current rules on those two pages. To manage stock and orders from one place across both channels, see what marketplace integration is.
4. Compare control over price, brand and operations
Before the numbers, there is the question of control. On a marketplace dozens of sellers can list the same product, your price sits next to a competitor’s one click away, and the campaign calendar is often in the platform’s hands. Your brand story has to fit the narrow space of a product page. In return the shop window, payment trust and delivery network are ready.
On your own shop you decide the price, the pack, the page design, the campaign and the message the customer receives. In return payment, security, speed and the quality of product pages are your responsibility; for that, see the seven jobs in how to set up an online shop.
Operations differ too. On a marketplace, delivery, returns and customer questions run by the platform’s rules, and you are expected to follow them. On your own shop the rules are yours, but you need a process for each: who packs, who takes the return, who answers the question. Don’t open a second channel before you have written that process down.
5. Work out margin per channel with your own numbers
This step settles the decision. Pick your three best-selling products and do the same calculation for each one, separately for the two channels:
- Write the selling price excluding VAT.
- Subtract the product cost and packaging.
- Subtract the channel’s share of the sale: commission on a marketplace, payment commission on your own shop.
- Subtract shipping, advertising and the share of returns.
- On your own shop, add the per-order share of the shop and measurement costs.
- Put the profit per order and the margin side by side.
You can do the first four lines, apart from advertising, with the marketplace profit calculator; it contains no ready-made commission rates, and you enter the rates from your own panel. Watch for two things when you read the result. First, turnover is not profit: a product with high turnover on a marketplace can leave little for you because its margin is low. Second, the profit of a single order does not show the value of a customer; on your own shop a repeat customer can pay for themselves overall even if the first order is weak. If you don’t know your repeat purchase rate, measure that first.
6. Add the second channel in order
For most businesses the real question is not which one to choose but which one to build first. Add the second channel while the first one runs smoothly: stock is right, cancellations are few, return reasons are recorded. Building both channels from scratch at the same time leaves both half done.
If you start on a marketplace, first work out margin per channel, then begin recording customer data and return reasons (as far as the platform allows), and then open your own shop as the second channel. If you start on your own shop, measure it with real orders, put stock and price in one place, and add a marketplace after that.
Once the second channel is open, price and stock must be managed with the same logic, otherwise the same product tells two different stories in two places. How we set this up and run it week by week is described on our e-commerce and marketplace service page.
Common mistakes
- Deciding from turnover. Assuming a channel is profitable because turnover on the marketplace is growing. Decide by what is left after commission, shipping, advertising and returns.
- Forgetting line items. On your own shop the cost of the shop and effort, on a marketplace returns and advertising, easily drop out of the calculation.
- Assuming you own the customer. Counting marketplace customers as your own without reading the limits on how that data may be used.
- Opening both channels from scratch together. One settles first, then the second is added.
- Keeping separate stock in each channel. Selling the same product from separate stock in two channels brings cancellations and a lower seller score.
- Ignoring price across channels. If you sell for more on your own shop than on the marketplace, the customer compares and leaves; if you sell for less, you weaken your own marketplace sales.
Common questions
Should I open on a marketplace first or build my own shop first?
If your product is searched for as a category and you don’t yet have a known brand, a marketplace is the fast way to reach demand. If people already search for your brand name, or you have repeat customers, your own shop makes more sense. In both cases do the calculation in step 5.
If I sell on both, what should the price be?
Think about price together with margin per channel. Putting the same product at clearly different prices in two places pushes the customer to compare. Letting certain products lead on the marketplace and branded or bundled products lead on your own shop is one way to reduce price conflict.
Can I leave the marketplace and sell only on my own shop?
You can; make that decision by looking at demand as well as margin. First test, on a small group of products, whether your own shop can bring in the orders that now come from the marketplace. A sudden exit means losing ready-made demand overnight.
A step you can take alone today
Pick your best-selling product. From last month’s order records write down the selling price, product cost, commission, shipping and return share, and enter them in the marketplace profit calculator. Then note beside the result which items would change if you sold the same product on your own shop. Once the two columns sit side by side, half of the decision is made.
Sources
This article is general information, not legal, financial or technical advice. Platforms, their rules and the law change over time, so some details may have changed since 11 November 2026 or contain small errors. Before you make a decision for your business, check the current official sources or write to us.