Short answer
When choosing a social media agency, get the scope (strategy, production, community management, ads) in writing. Pages, the ad account and payment method should be in your name, with the agency working through a role or partner access. Write down approvals, reply times and report contents before you sign.
The first month with an agency goes well: the visuals come out regularly and a report arrives. In month eight the two sides part. The owner, trying to log in to the Instagram account, finds that the email address it was created with belongs to an agency employee and that the ad account sits in the agency’s portfolio. The most practical answer to how to choose a social media agency is to prepare for that morning today. This article goes through what is specific to social media, in order: what the work really covers, who holds the accounts and the ad account, and the approval flow. Then come what a proposal must say in writing, what the report should contain and what happens on the day you leave. The general questions that apply to any agency are collected in how to choose a digital agency, and paid advertising has its own piece in how to choose a Google Ads agency. We don’t repeat them here.
1. Get what “social media management” covers in writing
The same two words can mean three posts a week in one proposal and, in another, a shooting crew, replies to comments and advertising. To compare proposals, split the work into parts and ask who handles each one:
| Part of the work | What it means | What to ask in the proposal |
|---|---|---|
| Strategy and voice guide | How the brand speaks, what it never says, the monthly goal | Will a written document be delivered, and who prepares it? |
| Content production | Copy, design, photography, short video | Who does the shooting, and who keeps the rights to the material? |
| Publishing and scheduling | Calendar, scheduling tools, posting | Who writes the calendar, and when does each post go out? |
| Community management | Replies to comments and messages | In which hours, within what time, and who replies? |
| Advertising | Paid posts and campaigns | Is it inside the proposal or a separate job? |
| Collaborations and reputation | Choosing influencers, crisis preparation | In scope or separate? |
| Report | The month’s results | How often, and with which numbers? |
The “separate job?” questions in the table matter because community management and advertising quietly drop out of many proposals. Our own social media and reputation service covers the voice guide, the monthly plan, content production, community management, influencer collaborations, crisis preparation and the monthly report; advertising is a separate service. Whichever agency you pick, keep the scope in writing.
2. Whose name are the accounts, the ad account and the payment method in?
What makes a split hardest in social media is not the content but the access. Ask about four assets separately: the page and profile accounts, the ad account, the payment method and the content archive.
On Meta, the route is the business portfolio. According to Meta’s help page, adding a partner requires someone with full control of the business portfolio; the partner must also have its own business portfolio and share its ID. Assets can be shared with full control or with partial access limited to specific tasks. In other words, the page and the ad account stay in your portfolio and the agency works as a partner.
On LinkedIn the same logic sits in Page roles. According to LinkedIn’s help page, the super admin role carries every Page admin permission, including adding and removing other admins. Keep the super admin role on your own account and give the agency a role that fits the job, such as content admin.
In practice:
- Open the pages and profiles yourself with a company email and two-step verification, or take over the admin rights of the existing ones.
- Open the ad account yourself in your own business portfolio and add the agency as a partner.
- Let the ad budget go straight to the platform, from your own payment method, and have the agency fee on a separate invoice.
- Have the contract state that the rights to shoot files, designs and copy pass to you.
If an agency says “let us open the account, it’s quicker”, ask why, and get the handover on the day you leave written down now.
3. Approvals: who signs off, and within how long
Both extremes cause trouble. With no approval at all, the agency may publish unchecked information in your brand’s name. An approval routine that asks for every post one by one pushes the agency into waiting and you into last-minute decisions. Ask for these to be written in the proposal:
- Who gives approval on your side, and who covers when they are away?
- How far ahead will the calendar arrive, and how many working days are allowed for approval?
- If the time runs out, does the post go live or wait? (The default answer should be “it waits”.)
- On sensitive subjects, such as health, law or price information, is there a second approver?
- Who has the authority to stop scheduled posts if the news agenda changes suddenly?
We showed how to build the calendar and its approval columns step by step in how to build a social media content calendar; you can ask the agency for the same structure. In regulated sectors such as clinics, the approval flow carries even more weight; we cover it in social media in healthcare.
4. Community management: who replies to comments, and when
Agencies promise to prepare posts readily; the message inbox is what gets overlooked. Inbox in Meta Business Suite gathers messages and comments from Facebook and Instagram in one place and lets you assign a conversation to a teammate. The tool is there; what is usually missing is a named person responsible. Ask the agency: on which days and at what hours do you reply, which questions are passed to us (price, complaints, health), and what is the first step when a negative comment arrives? Get the answers in writing, including what happens outside working hours. Google reviews belong to the same routine.
5. What a proposal should contain
A good social media proposal states these items plainly:
- monthly content types and quantities, and on which platforms,
- who shoots and who designs, and how many revisions are included,
- reply times and the out-of-hours arrangement,
- whether advertising management is in scope, and in whose name the budget is spent,
- how often reports come and what they contain,
- contract term, termination conditions and account handover,
- transfer of rights: who owns the content and the archive.
If influencer collaborations are part of the proposal, add one more item. According to the Ministry of Trade’s guide for social media influencers, posts made in return for a benefit must disclose the commercial relationship, and advertisers, advertising agencies and influencers are each separately responsible for complying with the guide. Have the agency take on that labelling in the contract. We walk through the collaboration step by step in how to run an influencer collaboration.
6. What the report should show
A follower count makes a nice headline but decides nothing on its own. Ask for the report to be tied to the brand’s goal: what was the goal this month, which content brought what, and how many real enquiries came out of the messages. A short monthly report can carry:
- the month’s goal and where things stand against it,
- the content that was saved, shared and brought messages the most,
- the number of messages and enquiries received and how they ended,
- reply times to comments and messages,
- the changes planned for next month.
Expect a paragraph of interpretation beside the numbers: why it worked, why it did not. If ads are running, the platform’s report and the sales in your till should sit side by side, and why the two numbers can differ should be discussed at the start.
7. Red flags
- A guarantee of followers, likes or comments. No agency can guarantee a platform’s outcome, and bought followers do not add value to an account.
- Opening the accounts in its own name and not sharing access. That risks losing the history when you leave.
- The ad budget passing through the agency. If you cannot see the platform invoice, you cannot know how much of the money went into ads.
- Offering only follower counts as references. Ask what an account the agency runs added to its goal.
- A ready-made package. An agency that offers the same package without listening to you does not know your brand’s voice.
- Silence on reply times and the approval flow.
8. The day you leave: what to ask for in the handover
The exit plan belongs in the contract from day one. If the accounts are yours, handover is short: you remove the agency’s role and add the new one. Still, get these in writing: delivery of all content and shoot files, a copy of the voice guide and monthly plans, the ready-made replies, the list of scheduled posts and a list of user roles. On the advertising side, make sure the campaign history stays in your account. We walk through that transition in changing your ad agency.
Common mistakes
- Comparing proposals by number of posts, without checking whether community management and advertising are in scope.
- Leaving account setup to the agency and never looking at the role list.
- Starting without a written approval flow.
- Looking only at followers and likes in the report.
- Finding it rude to discuss the exit on day one.
Common questions
Should I use a social media agency or an in-house team?
If you need production, shooting and community management together across several platforms, an agency can share the work. For one platform and few posts, an in-house person or a single specialist may be enough. The decision depends on how many jobs there are and how much time the person who approves can set aside.
How does the agency get access to my accounts?
On Meta you share the assets in your business portfolio through partner access; you can choose full control or only specific tasks. On LinkedIn the agency is given an admin role on the Page. In both cases ownership and admin authority stay with you, and you can remove the access whenever you like.
Will I lose my accounts if I change agency?
Not if they were opened in your name: you add the new agency and remove the old one. With accounts opened in the agency’s name, the history and access are at risk. That is why ownership should be settled before you sign.
One step you can take alone today: open the role lists of your Instagram, Facebook, LinkedIn and ad accounts, and write on a sheet of paper whose email address each one is. Any line you do not recognise, or that is an agency employee’s personal address, is the first item to raise with the agency.
Sources
This article is general information, not legal, financial or technical advice. Platforms, their rules and the law change over time, so some details may have changed since 11 November 2026 or contain small errors. Before you make a decision for your business, check the current official sources or write to us.