Short answer
A good email subject line is one promise the email actually keeps: first write what the email gives in a single sentence, then shorten the subject line from that sentence. Read it together with the sender name and preview, check it on a phone and compare options without relying on open rate alone.
Picture this: there is a fictional online tea shop, and every example in this article belongs to that invented firm. The shop sends its list an email headed “Don’t miss out: huge deal!” There is no discount inside, only a new tasting set. A reader who opens it on that subject finds nothing of what they came for on the first screen and closes it; some unsubscribe the same day. The copy is not badly written; the subject line made a promise the email did not keep. That is where the answer to how to write an email subject line starts: first decide what the email will deliver, then turn that promise into a short, clear sentence.
Our newsletter guide gives a short table for the subject line and preview; you can find it in how to write an email newsletter. Here we take seven steps you can use for any kind of send. The detailed method for comparing two options is in the A/B testing guide; this article takes only the part adapted to subject lines.
1. Write the subject line as a promise the email keeps
Before writing the subject line, write the single purpose of the email in one sentence: “This email gives the reader this.” The subject line is the short form of that sentence. Then ask yourself: when the reader opens the email, does the first screen show what that sentence says?
Gmail’s sender guidelines are plain on this: the subject, headers, display names and other elements of a message should accurately represent the sender’s identity and the message content, and should not be misleading. The page’s example is not to start a subject line with “Re:” or “Fwd:” unless the message really is a reply or a forward.
The same page says that if messages from a domain are frequently reported as spam, future messages are more likely to be marked as spam, and that user spam reports can lower the domain’s reputation over time. This conclusion is ours and the page does not state it: a misleading subject line does not only lose that one reader; if it turns into complaints it can also make later sends harder to deliver. Authenticating the domain is a separate job, covered in the SPF, DKIM and DMARC guide.
2. Build the sender name, subject and preview as one sentence
In the inbox the reader sees three things one after another: who it is from, the subject line and the preview text. Write them as three parts of one sentence. For the tea shop, for example:
- Sender name: “Example Tea House”
- Subject line: “The tasting set is here: six teas, one box”
- Preview: “If you do not know which tea to choose for a first order, start here.”
The preview does not repeat the subject line; it adds a second detail. If you leave it empty, the inbox mostly shows the first lines of the message (this is our own observation), so check in advance what those lines say.
For the sender name, Gmail’s display name guidelines say two things: the display name should identify the sender only and should not include the subject or message content. Among the examples to avoid, the page lists names such as “TIME IS RUNNING OUT (SALE)”, “URGENT REQUEST” and “Last Chance”. It also asks that the display name not include the recipient’s name or imply a reply or a threaded conversation. So what the subject line has to say is not moved into the sender name. Keeping the sender name the same in every send is our own recommendation: the reader should not have to wonder who this is from.
3. Check how much shows on a phone
In the subject line advice it gives its own users, Mailchimp says that for many recipients, especially those reading on mobile, shorter is often better, and recommends no more than 9 words and 60 characters. This is advice from a service provider to its own users, and according to the page it rests on analysis of the open rates of emails sent through Mailchimp; Gmail’s guidelines set no such limit. So do not treat it as a rule; take it as a starting point.
What you can do is simpler: put the main information of the subject line first, send the email to your own phone and to a second email app, and see where it is cut off. If meaning is lost at the cut, rebuild the sentence. The cut-off point changes with the app and the screen, so do not rely on a fixed number.
4. Choose the specific over the clever
The same Mailchimp page says that it is sometimes better to be direct and descriptive than trendy. It says seasonal slogans such as “Fall into savings” offer no specific hook, and suggests describing the benefit of a promotion or calling attention to the specific deal. We share this view, because a specific subject line makes the promise checkable: the reader knows what is on offer, and it is clear whether the email kept it.
Before and after pairs for the invented tea shop:
| Before | After | Why it is better |
|---|---|---|
| Don’t miss out: huge deal! | The tasting set is here: six teas, one box | Says what has arrived and what is in it |
| Example Tea House Newsletter, Issue 14 | The three most common mistakes when brewing tea | Names what the reader will get |
| Big news! | Delivery times will be longer in holiday week | Says plainly what the news is |
| News as warm as your tea | The winter blend is back in stock | Information in place of a joke |
| We miss you! | Two items are left in your basket | Ties to something the reader did |
| HURRY LAST DAYS!!! | The winter blend sale ends on Sunday night | Names the day of the deadline, without shouting |
All the pairs are illustrations; the tea shop, its products and its dates are invented. You can use a joke; but what the reader will receive should still show beneath it.
5. Where to personalise and where not to
Mailchimp recommends adding the recipient’s name or location to the subject line with merge tags, and says personalisation may work well with targeted automations such as birthday offers and post-purchase follow-ups. Again, this advice is for that company’s own users and concerns open rate. The part that is our own advice is this: personalisation carries most meaning when it ties to something the reader did, like “Two items are left in your basket”.
The places where it backfires are just as concrete; these three points are our own observation and are not on Mailchimp’s page:
- An empty field. If no name was saved, you get a subject line like “Hello ,”. Define a fallback value for every tag and try the field with a test contact that has nothing filled in.
- Name and grammar. In a language where a name takes an ending, one fixed pattern cannot be right for every name. In Turkish, for instance, the ending changes with the last sound of the name, so a template with one ending written in is correct for some names and wrong for others. If you send in such a language, put the name where it takes no ending: at the start or the end, set off by a comma.
- A wrong guess. If you guess a location or an interest and get it wrong, personalisation puts the reader off. Use only what the reader gave you or did.
The rule in Gmail’s guidelines that the recipient’s name should not be in the display name is about the sender name; we did not read anything on the same page that forbids the recipient’s name in the subject line.
6. Use emoji, capitals and punctuation sparingly
Mailchimp’s advice to its own users is: no more than one emoji at a time, an emoji that adds to the words and does not take their place, and no more than three punctuation marks. It also says too many marks can make an email look like spam. The same page adds that different operating systems display emoji differently, so they should be tested. Gmail’s guidelines cover another point: do not use emoji or other non-standard characters to imitate graphic elements with the intent to deceive or influence recipients. The page’s example is putting an emoji next to a display name to imply the name has been verified. So we did not read a rule that bans emoji in subject lines outright; what is to be avoided is emoji used to deceive.
For capitals we have no source to quote; this is our own advice: a whole word in capitals feels like being shouted at. Put emphasis in the word itself, in a date or in a number. We also do not give a list of words to avoid: the sources this article relies on do not say that a single word sends an email to spam. What Gmail’s guidelines dwell on is not misleading, sending only to people who want the messages, and not drawing spam complaints.
7. Compare two subject lines fairly
If you have to choose between two subject lines, set up the comparison with these rules:
- Only the subject line differs. Sender name, preview, content and send time stay the same.
- Split recipients at random. “One to the morning list and the other to the evening list” is not a test.
- Choose the measure before sending. Clicks, or the action the email is really for: a form, an order, an appointment.
- Do not read the result before there are enough recipients. If your list is small, a difference between two subject lines may well be chance; in that case, instead of testing, write one clear subject line and note the result. To work out the number you need, see the A/B test sample size calculator.
Why can open rate alone mislead in subject line tests? Apple’s Mail user guide for Mac says that remote content in incoming messages may let a sender collect information such as when and how many times a message is viewed, and that Mail Privacy Protection prevents this. With the option on, remote content is downloaded in the background when the message is received, not when it is viewed. Our reading is this: for recipients who have turned this option on, an “open” may not show real reading, and we cannot know how many are in that position. Mailchimp’s account of its test also describes a set-up that sends the version with the best open rate to the remaining recipients. Confirm the result with clicks or the action as well. We walk through how tools split the list and which metric should pick the winner in the email A/B testing guide. The term open rate is explained briefly in the glossary.
In Detmore’s email and CRM service, subject line, timing and content tests run every month and open rate is not taken as the only measure; we look at the sales a flow brings, unsubscribe and complaint rates and deliverability. Think about the subject lines in automated flows together with the message order described in the email automation guide.
Five questions before you send
- Does the first screen of the email keep the promise in the subject line?
- Do the sender name, subject and preview read together as one sentence?
- Is the main information of the subject line visible on your phone?
- What shows when the personalisation field is empty?
- Does the subject start with “Re:” or “Fwd:”, and how many emoji and capitalised words does it have?
Common mistakes
- Pasting a subject line that worked in one send onto another email with different content: that subject fitted that email’s promise.
- Changing the preview or the sender name while testing the subject line; you cannot tell which one worked.
- Drawing a general rule from the difference in a single send.
Common questions
How many characters should a subject line be?
We did not read a length limit for subject lines in Gmail’s sender guidelines. Mailchimp recommends no more than 9 words and 60 characters to its own users; take that as a starting point and try the email on your own phone.
Should I use emoji in a subject line?
You do not have to. Mailchimp recommends to its own users no more than one emoji at a time, used to add to the words and not replace them, and tested on different operating systems. Gmail asks that emoji not be used to deceive, for example to imply that a name has been verified.
If the open rate is high, is the subject line good?
Not on that evidence alone. According to Apple’s guide, with Mail Privacy Protection on, remote content is downloaded in the background when a message is received. In our reading, that is why the open count may not reflect real reading. Look at clicks and the action as well.
One thing you can do alone today: open the last email you sent, write in one sentence what it gave the reader on its first screen, and compare that sentence with the subject line. If they do not say the same thing, write the subject line of your next send by shortening that sentence.
Sources
This article is general information, not legal, financial or technical advice. Platforms, their rules and the law change over time, so some details may have changed since 14 November 2026 or contain small errors. Before you make a decision for your business, check the current official sources or write to us.