How to segment an email list: start with 4 segments

Which data to split on, which four segments to start with, why a tag is not a segment, and how to tell whether a segment is worth its upkeep.

· 11 min readEmail

Short answer

Email segmentation splits a list into groups by rules such as sign-up source, purchase history and engagement. Start with four segments: new subscribers, people who have not bought, customers and lapsed readers. Add a consent condition to each, and delete any segment that never gets its own message.

On Tuesday morning the autumn sale email from Yeşil Köşe, a fictional online plant shop, goes to the whole list at once. A customer who bought three pots last week sees “a discount on your first order”. Someone who has never bought anything gets a suggestion for an accessory to a product they don’t own. A third person, who joined only for the watering calendar, never opens it again. Email list segmentation means splitting the list into groups by rules, so that you can write three different messages for these three people. This guide covers which data to split on, which four segments to start with, and when a segment earns its upkeep.

If your list is still small or you use a single form, read how to grow an email list first. Most of the data a segment uses is collected on that sign-up form.

What a segment is for, and what it is not

A segment is a group of people who match a rule, and it updates by itself. “Has placed at least two orders” is a rule; a person joins the group when they place the second order. The only job of a segment is to let you send different groups different messages. If two groups will get the same message, there is no point in separating them.

A segment does not sell anything on its own. If the message is weak, you simply send a weak message to a smaller group. So the order is simple: decide which group needs which different message, then build the segment.

Which data to split on

Four kinds of data cover most businesses. The table below shows what each says, an example rule and what to watch.

Data What it tells you Example rule Watch out for
Behaviour What the person did on the site Viewed a product page in the last 30 days, no order Behaviour data depends on tracking being set up and on cookie consent
Purchase history What they bought and when Has placed at least two orders Check that orders really reach the tool
Engagement What they do with your messages At least one click in the last five sends Don’t rely on opens alone; our list guide explains why
Sign-up source Which promise brought them in Joined through the watering calendar form Mark the source at sign-up; it can’t be recovered later

Sign-up source is the data most often forgotten. If you don’t mark a field or tag for each form, a year later you won’t know who joined on which promise. Treat customer and order data as first-party data: information you collected through your own channels and hold yourself.

Start with four segments

Our suggestion is to start with at most four to six segments. These four are enough for the first month in most shops and service sites.

  1. New subscribers. People whose sign-up date is recent. They are in the welcome series and should not receive campaigns meanwhile; see how to set up a welcome email series.
  2. Subscribers who haven’t ordered. On the list, with zero orders. Messages that lead to a first purchase are written for this group.
  3. Customers. At least one order. You can split off “two or more orders” later; the repeat purchase rate calculator shows how many people buy again.
  4. Lapsed readers. People who haven’t clicked or ordered for a long time. “Long” depends on your sales cycle: a month for something bought often, perhaps a year for something bought rarely. This group is the entry to the win-back flow, which we describe in how to set up email automation.

One person can sit in several segments at once. Before you send a campaign, write down which segment takes priority, or the same person will get two campaigns.

Six steps to build one segment

  1. Write the purpose in one sentence. For example, “send a first-order message to subscribers who haven’t bought”. If you can’t write the sentence, you don’t need the segment.
  2. Start the rule with one piece of data. Begin with just “orders equal zero”. Adding conditions is easy; finding out why a rule with many conditions returns nobody is hard.
  3. Add the consent condition. Limit the rule to people who can receive marketing email. The consent section below explains why.
  4. Name it so the name explains the rule. “No order, joined over 30 days ago”. In three months you shouldn’t need to look anywhere else to remember the rule.
  5. Test it with your own address. Check whether your test address matches the rule. If it doesn’t, the rule isn’t doing what you meant.
  6. Look at the count before you send. A number far from what you expected is usually a data or rule error.

Segments, tags and lists are not the same in every tool

The same word means different things in different tools, so check the documentation of the one you use. Here is how it works in three common tools.

Tool Group filled by hand or by form Group filled by rule Worth knowing
Klaviyo List: filled by form, by hand or by import Segment: grows and shrinks with its conditions You can’t add people to a segment by hand or import them
Mailchimp Tag: a marker you put on a contact Segment: recalculated from its conditions A tag and a static segment are the same object
HubSpot Static segment: holds the members it had when processed Active segment: records that match join, others leave What HubSpot used to call lists are now called segments

These come from the vendors’ own pages. Klaviyo’s segments and lists article describes lists as static and segments as condition-based and dynamic. Mailchimp’s developer documentation says static segments are also tags. HubSpot’s segment page says active segments update their members automatically and static ones do not.

In practice, a static group is enough for a one-off announcement. For something that keeps changing, such as “date of last order”, you need a rule-based segment. A tag is not rule-based: it is a marker put on a person by you or by a form, and it doesn’t change by itself. If you haven’t chosen a tool yet, Klaviyo or HubSpot compares the two.

Segmentation does not grant permission, and it doesn’t make it easier to write to people who haven’t given it. There are three limits.

  • Consent first. Law No. 6563 says commercial electronic messages may be sent to recipients only with their prior consent (Article 6). That applies whichever segment someone is in.
  • The scope of the consent. The same law requires the content of a message to match the consent obtained from the recipient (Article 7). If the form promised only a watering calendar, sending that person an unrelated campaign may not fit the promise. We suggest building segments around what the form promised.
  • The right to refuse. Recipients can refuse messages at any time, and sending must stop within three working days of the request reaching you (Article 8). Make sure people who have opted out sit in no segment you send to.

The tools carry a warning of their own. Klaviyo’s documentation says segments draw from all profiles in the account, including people who haven’t opted in to marketing. So add a “can receive marketing” condition with AND to every segment.

Using personal data for segmentation is a separate matter. Law No. 6698 requires data to be processed for specific, explicit and legitimate purposes, and to be relevant, limited and proportionate to them (Article 4). We suggest using only what a person told you or did with you in a rule, and saying so in your privacy notice. For detail, read email and SMS consent in Türkiye and ask a legal adviser.

Is the segment worth its upkeep

Every segment has a cost: keeping the rule current, writing messages, reading the result. We keep a segment only if we can answer yes to four questions.

Four questions that decide whether a segment is worth keeping 1 Will this group get a different message? 2 Is the group big enough to read a result? 3 Can we compare its result with the rest of the list? 4 Is the data behind the rule still current? Any question a no: merge it or delete it Yes to all four: the segment stays Four questions that decide whether a segment is worth keeping 1 Will this group get a different message? 2 Is the group big enough to read a result? 3 Can we compare its result with the rest of the list? 4 Is the data behind the rule still current? Yes to all four: the segment stays Any question a no: merge it or delete it
Figure: A segment that passes all four questions stays in upkeep; a no to any of them means merging it into another segment or deleting it.

The fourth question is the one most often skipped. If the “date of last order” field hasn’t flowed into the tool for months, a “no order in the last 90 days” segment contains everyone and quietly misleads you.

Here is an example for the second question. Say a segment at Yeşil Köşe holds only 40 people, and across two campaigns 3 then 5 of them click. That gap is chance, not a result. Merging the segment into a larger one gives a more honest reading.

When you read results, compare the segment with the rest of the list in the same send, and look at clicks and orders; opens alone can mislead. Once a month, write four lines for each segment: the rule, the last send it was used in, the last result, and whether it stays. Delete any segment you can’t write the lines for.

Common mistakes

  • Starting with ten segments. Each group needs its own message; a segment without one sits idle.
  • Forgetting the consent condition. Segments built from order data in particular can include customers who haven’t agreed to marketing.
  • Not documenting the rule. Nobody remembers who a segment called “VIP” covers six months later.
  • Mixing static and dynamic groups. A static group doesn’t update by itself; sending a campaign today to a customer group built three months ago is the result.
  • Never reading the result. Sends go out, but nobody compares whether the segment helped.

Segment setup, the template system and CRM fields are part of our email and CRM service.

Common questions

How many subscribers do I need to segment?

Our sources don’t give a threshold. Our own test is that a segment must be big enough to read a result from. If the list is small, start with two or three segments and split further as it grows.

Is a tag the same as a segment?

It depends on the tool. In Mailchimp’s developer documentation a tag is the same object as a static segment, while a condition-based segment is recalculated as data changes. HubSpot separates static and active segments. Read the documentation of your own tool.

Consent to commercial messages is needed to send them; a segment rule is a use of personal data. Make sure the data in your rule is described in your privacy notice. This is general information, not legal advice.

One step you can take alone today

Open your tool and build a single segment: “has not clicked in the last five sends and can receive marketing email”. Don’t send anything; just look at how many people it returns and write the number down. When you see what share of the whole list that is, you can decide whether the group deserves a message of its own.

Sources

This article is general information, not legal, financial or technical advice. Platforms, their rules and the law change over time, so some details may have changed since 15 November 2026 or contain small errors. Before you make a decision for your business, check the current official sources or write to us.

Tell us about
your project.

Fill in the form or write to us directly, and we will agree on a day to talk.

Your first meeting is with Deniz Sezer, founder of Detmore.

First meeting free · Reply within one working day · Written proposal in 2 to 3 days · NDA ready

What do you need? pick as many as you like

Name, email and phone are required.

Contact

We reply within one working day.